Schedule a Tour
Choose your date. It's free cancel anytime.
618 S Palmetto Avenue, Sanford, FL
OPEN HOUSE - Saturday, July 26th, 2025 from 11am to 3pm
Every once in a while, a home comes along that truly stops you in your tracks—and this is it! This is your chance to own one of Sanford’s most iconic homes! Known lovingly by locals as the Alligator Inn, this 3 Bedroom + Den + Office 1900 Queen Anne-style gem is not only rich in character, but also rich in story. Featured three times as a Porchfest host and proudly listed on the National Register of Historic Places, this unforgettable corner-lot home sits on one of the most picturesque blocks in Sanford’s beloved historic district.
From the moment you arrive, the wraparound porch sweeps you off your feet. With an idyllic porch swing that practically begs you to slow down and stay awhile, this is the perfect spot for morning coffee, evening cocktails, or long conversations with friends that last well past sunset.
Step into the backyard retreat, and you’ll find just as much charm. The mix of artificial turf, paver patio, and spacious deck gives you versatile outdoor living year-round. And don’t forget the mango tree, offering up plenty of fresh, juicy fruit every summer—mango salsa or mango margaritas, anyone?
Inside, this bright and cheerful home boasts hardwood floors throughout, a cozy living room with a fireplace, a fully remodeled kitchen (2018) with timeless white cabinetry, granite countertops, and stainless steel appliances, plus a full bath downstairs and a home office with a convenient half bath. Upstairs, you’ll find three more bedrooms and another remodeled bathroom (2022). The beautiful stained glass windows, built-in window seats, and classic detailing speaks to the home’s rich history.
One major bonus? The home was just professionally tented for termites, so you can move in with peace of mind knowing that big-ticket item is already taken care of. Even better—the home was painted in 2021 and the roof (2021), gas tankless water heater (2018) and AC (3 zones upstairs and a special ionizer) are all newer, giving you even more confidence in the home’s upkeep and long-term value.
And there’s more: the detached 2-car garage (expertly constructed in 2013 with permits) includes an upstairs bonus room that could easily become a private apartment, studio, gym, or hobby space. Tons of storage and parking (even off street outside) for your cars, golf cart, or weekend toys make it practical as well as charming.
If you’ve been watching this one, now’s your chance—homes like this don’t come up often. In fact, it hasn’t been available in almost 20 years.
Living in Sanford: A Slice of Small-Town America
Downtown Sanford isn’t Central Florida’s best-kept secret anymore—because the secret’s out. People are discovering what locals have known all along: Sanford is where charm meets community. Picture quiet weekday mornings strolling past historic homes, biking around Lake Monroe at sunset, or hopping in your golf cart for dinner, a brewery tour, or a bit of downtown thrifting.
This is a walkable, bikeable, lovable lifestyle—where neighbors become friends, and the porch is as important as the living room. Whether it’s Sunday Funday, live music at a local pub, or catching the free shuttle to SunRail for a car-free trip to Winter Park or Orlando, Sanford offers the kind of connected, low-key, joyful living that’s hard to find elsewhere.
Plus, with easy access to 417 and I-4 and top-rated Seminole County schools, this charming town delivers both convenience and quality of life.
And perhaps best of all? The people. Sanford is a true community, where friendly faces, local pride, and a shared love of small-town living bring everything to life.
Property Details
| Property Type | Residential |
|---|---|
| Mls # | O6328662 |
| LotSize | 0.13 acres |
| Property Subtype | Single Family Home |
| Year Built | 1910 |
Photos
Get Top Dollar for Your Home
With Our 100+ Point Marketing Plan!
Learn how we will get your home:
- In front of and shown to more buyers
- Sold faster and for more money
- Sold on your terms without the hassle and stress
Real Estate Resource Center
Real Estate Reports for Home Owners, Sellers & Buyers!
Maps & Local
Schools
Print Brochure
Reviews
We recently sold our home in Oviedo with the help of Jose, and we couldn't be more grateful for his support and guidance throughout the process. From day one, Jose impressed us with his clear...
04/10/2025 - mkbascones
Read more
Jose and Claudia are wonderful to work with! We have used them for both buying and selling now and in both cases everything was handled professionally and went smoothly. They offered suggestions...
05/23/2024 - KLindell05
Read more
Quiero agradecer a José y Claudia por el excelente trabajo que hicieron al vender nuestra casa. Pasaron tan solo 10 días desde que llame a José hasta el día que se vendió la casa. Nos asesoró...
09/13/2023 - ivaneskacalixto
Read more
I have purchased and sold 9 houses. Jose was by far the best informed and best negotiator that I have worked with. I am in sales for a living. He was very well informed, not just on the market but...
11/08/2022 - PTD
Read more
Claudia and Jose made shopping for and purchasing a house so easy. They were amazingly helpful from the first e-mail contact, to looking at homes to the purchase process. The ability to have two...
05/28/2022 - bskopeck
Read more
View more reviewsMy experience with Jose was amazing. Buying a home from across the country in this market is a difficult task, Jose made it become a very easy task, If I had a question, He had an answer, he always...
05/01/2022 - zuser20220315225256093
Read more
View More Listings
Click the property below to view the virtual tour of each listing.
